Goods fail soon after purchase: must I prove the exact cause?
A retailer suggests you used the product incorrectly. What consumers in Germany must actually prove after an early failure, how the one-year presumption helps and which evidence to keep.
What did the BGH decide?
A used car bought in August 2020 burned out in a car park in early September. The comprehensive insurer paid the loss and sought recovery from the dealer under the rights transferred to it. A technical defect was a possible cause, as was arson. The lower courts considered the necessary proof lacking. The Federal Court of Justice rejected that approach (VIII ZR 73/24, paragraphs 1 to 5, 12 and 17 to 28).
What matters is an apparent defect: an adverse condition for which at least one possible cause would give rise to the seller’s liability for defects. The buyer need not rule out every other possible cause before relying on the presumption. The dealer must, however, have an opportunity to rebut it. The case therefore went back to the Cologne Higher Regional Court (paragraphs 23, 28 and 34 to 37).
When does the one-year period help?
The rule concerns a consumer buying from a business, such as an appliance from an electronics retailer or a used car from a dealer. This particular evidential protection does not apply to purchases from private sellers (German Civil Code, section 474). For purchases under current law, the general period is one year from the transfer of risk, normally delivery. The problem must become apparent during that time. The goods are then generally presumed to have been defective when the risk passed to the buyer. This is neither a one-year durability guarantee nor a general deadline for complaints. Its expiry does not automatically make defect claims time-barred (sections 477 and 438).
The court dealt with a purchase made in 2020, when the earlier six-month period still applied. The current one-year period is set out in section 477(1). Special rules apply to live animals and certain digital elements. This article focuses on ordinary purchases of goods and technical defects.
An example: a washing machine stops after eight months
Suppose you buy a new washing machine from a retailer. Eight months after delivery, it repeatedly stops mid-cycle during normal use. You record the date, error message and load. The retailer merely replies that you may have used it incorrectly. If a technical fault is a possible cause and you can prove that the problem appeared in time, that suggestion alone does not defeat the statutory presumption. You generally do not first have to identify the defective component yourself.
The position is different if the retailer can prove that the problem was caused by an event occurring after delivery for which it is not responsible. How you actually used the product therefore remains relevant. Describe that accurately and allow an inspection. The additional Federal Court of Justice case concerning a scooter also stresses that the buyer may need to explain how they handled the item (VIII ZR 257/23, paragraphs 52 to 55).
What are the limits of the presumption?
If the only possible causes are ones that do not give rise to the seller’s liability for defects, such as ordinary wear and tear, the required apparent defect is absent. Section 477 also provides an exception where the presumption is incompatible with the nature of the goods or their condition. Mere suspicion cannot replace the necessary factual basis (VIII ZR 73/24, paragraphs 19 and 23).
The Munich Higher Regional Court distinguished a purely precautionary recall covering an entire model range where no specific defect had become apparent in the purchased car. The appeal failed (order of 4 September 2026, 21 U 1143/26 e, paragraphs 20 to 24). This does not establish a blanket exclusion for recalls. The official record lists proceedings before the Federal Court of Justice under VIII ZR 201/26; no final decision in those proceedings has been verified here.
What should you record and request?
The evidential rule alone does not create an immediate right to a refund. Usually the first step is to seek a repair or replacement. Ending the contract, reducing the price and claiming damages require further conditions to be met (German Civil Code, sections 437, 439 and 475d). Contact the seller with a specific description of the problem and make the goods available for inspection and a remedy.
- Keep the receipt and delivery date to establish the contracting parties and the start of the period.
- Record the problem, when it first appeared and how the product was used, with photographs, video, error messages or witnesses.
- Keep correspondence and inspection reports. Before arranging repairs yourself or disposing of the product, consider preservation of evidence and the seller’s rights.
Sources & further information
- Federal Court of Justice judgment of 6 May 2026, VIII ZR 73/24: burden of proof after a car fire ↗
- Federal Court of Justice judgment of 6 May 2026, VIII ZR 257/23: additional scooter case ↗
- Munich Higher Regional Court order of 4 September 2026, 21 U 1143/26 e: precautionary recall ↗
- Section 477 of the German Civil Code on the presumption concerning defects ↗
- Section 474 of the German Civil Code on consumer sales ↗
- Section 438 of the German Civil Code on limitation of defect claims ↗
- Section 437 of the German Civil Code on remedies for defects ↗
- Section 439 of the German Civil Code on repair and replacement ↗
- Section 475d of the German Civil Code on ending a consumer sales contract and claiming damages ↗
This article provides general guidance. The options available depend on your specific situation.