DR. SARAFI Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbHFrankfurt am Main · Throughout Germany
Tenancy law

Can my landlord charge me for cable TV through my service charges?

Since July 2024, the monthly cable TV fee can no longer be passed on through service charges in Germany. Which costs of the building’s equipment may still be billed, and what does the Karlsruhe ruling mean for tenants?

Editor: DR. SARAFI Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH4 mins

What is the landlord charging for?

Landlords used to be able to order cable TV for the whole building and, if the tenancy agreement provided for it, split the monthly fee among all flats. Even tenants who never watched cable TV had to contribute. That arrangement for the monthly fee ended on 30 June 2024 at the latest. What matters is the period the fee covers. If you have an individual TV contract with a provider or your landlord, that contract governs its charges (Operating Costs Ordinance, section 2, first sentence, point 15(b), and judgment, paragraphs 5 to 7 and 73).

Check what kind of system the building uses and when it was installed. For a private distribution system connected to a broadband network and installed before 1 December 2021, only the electricity used to run it can be billed under point (b) from July 2024. For a communal aerial of the same age, point (a) also allows regular checks that it is working, including adjustment by a qualified technician. In each case the tenancy agreement must provide for the cost to be passed on. Neither rule applies to installations built on or after 1 December 2021. A separate charge for providing fibre infrastructure has its own legal conditions (Operating Costs Ordinance, section 2, first sentence, point 15(a) to (c), and second sentence, and German Civil Code, section 556(1) and (3a)).

Why could a landlord end the building’s supply contract?

Operators often invested in cabling in return for years of agreed payments. When landlords lost the ability to pass on the charges, they could still owe the provider money. Section 230(5) of the German Telecommunications Act gives both parties to a supply contract made before 1 December 2021 a special right to terminate. Because of the restriction on passing on charges, either party can terminate without a notice period, with effect from 1 July 2024 at the earliest, unless they agreed otherwise for that situation. Termination on this ground does not itself entitle the other party to damages (judgment, paragraphs 7, 67 to 69, 84 and 97).

The court recognised that operators could lose future income already secured by contract. Factors favouring the legislation included the transition period, the priority given to the parties’ own agreements and the long-term revenues operators had enjoyed under the old system. The court also considered tenants’ freedom to obtain information under Article 5(1), first sentence, of Germany’s Basic Law. It protects access to broadcasts and to the equipment needed to receive them (paragraphs 46 to 49, 71 to 74 and 92 to 97).

For tenants, the scope of the judgment matters. The right to terminate the building’s contract belongs to the parties to it. A tenant cannot use this provision to end the landlord’s contract. The operator that also challenged the Operating Costs Ordinance failed to show that the provision affected its own rights. The court ruled neither on an individual statement nor on a refund to tenants (paragraphs 37 to 43 and 67).

An example from a 2025 service charge statement

Suppose your statement for January to December 2025 lists €108 for the “cable system”. When asked, your landlord produces a provider’s invoice showing twelve monthly connection fees of €9 each. That gives you a specific ground to object because the amount is for cable service after the cut-off date. If the document instead shows electricity for the building’s distribution equipment, check the type and age of the system, the terms of the tenancy and the share allocated to your flat. The same wording on a statement can cover two different costs.

How do I raise an objection?

Identify the statement, the disputed item, the billing period and your reason for objecting. If several costs are combined, you can ask to inspect the supporting documents. The landlord may provide them electronically (German Civil Code, section 556(4)). For example, ask to see the invoice showing the monthly fee separately from the electricity used to run the system.

Record the date you received the statement. You generally have twelve months from receipt to notify your landlord of objections. A late objection is still possible if you were not responsible for the delay (German Civil Code, section 556(3), fifth and sixth sentences). Keep a copy of your objection and evidence showing when your landlord received it.

Sources & further information

This article provides general guidance. The options available depend on your specific situation.

Explore this practice area Tenancy law

DR. SARAFI Rechtsanwälte

Your concern: tenancy law

Briefly describe your case and known deadlines. We clarify the takeover, the scope of services and the remuneration.

Get in touchBook a consultationinfo@sarafi.deAn engagement begins only when we expressly accept it.

English translation of our German website. Statutory references concern German or EU law. The German original remains available through the language selector.