Leased car written off: Is the insurer’s salvage offer binding?
Is your insurer deducting a high salvage offer? A Munich court judgment shows why the vehicle description, collection terms and lease matter.
Why does a high salvage value mean a smaller insurance payment?
Under the policy terms agreed in this case, the salvage value was deducted from the replacement value following a total loss. Salvage value meant the achievable sale price of the damaged car. A higher figure therefore meant a lower insurance payment (paragraphs 38 to 41).
A hypothetical example excluding any policy excess or other deductions: a replacement value of EUR 30,000 and a salvage value of EUR 10,000 leave EUR 20,000. If the salvage value is set at EUR 15,000, only EUR 15,000 remains.
The dispute concerned a leased electric car damaged in a hailstorm. Water entered through the broken rear window, the electronics failed and the car could no longer be driven. The insurer calculated its payment using a Lithuanian buyer’s offer of EUR 24,763 including VAT. The car was later sold to a different business for EUR 16,000 including VAT (paragraphs 3 to 7).
The court awarded a further EUR 7,363.86. This was the payment ordered in this particular case, not a standard amount for comparable losses. The conditions of the offer and the parties’ contractual arrangements were decisive.
Which two problems made the offer unreasonable?
First, the description of the car’s condition was incomplete. The listing mentioned electrical faults caused by water ingress, but did not say that the car could not be driven. The court therefore found a substantial risk of the buyer later bringing claims for defects. It referred to section 434 of the German Civil Code. Merely mentioning possible electrical damage was insufficient in this case (paragraph 47).
The argument that the insurer would be liable for inaccurate information did not resolve the issue. A dispute with the buyer and a separate claim against the insurer would have involved further litigation risks; the insurer had not submitted that it had acknowledged its liability (paragraph 48).
Second, collection arrangements were unclear. The offer did not establish either that the buyer would collect the car free of charge or that the insurer would pay for and organise transport. Even a professional leasing company did not have to accept this financial risk without further clarification (paragraphs 44 and 49).
Does this mean I can always sell to a local dealer?
No. The court maintained the principle that a reasonable offer arranged by the insurer must be taken into account under the applicable policy terms. An actual sale at a lower price does not automatically displace that offer. In this case, the lower proceeds could be used because accepting the offer had been found unreasonable (paragraphs 40 to 46).
A high price or a buyer based abroad does not automatically make an offer dubious. Following expert evidence, the court considered this particular bid genuine. Specialisation in electric vehicles and cheaper repair options could explain the price difference (paragraphs 50 to 52).
For the leased car, the court considered the circumstances of the leasing company as owner. The relevant market was therefore not restricted to German-speaking buyers. Someone using a leased car privately cannot infer a general right to have only local offers taken into account (paragraph 43).
What are the limits of the judgment?
The case concerned a claim under the policyholder’s own vehicle insurance and the AKB 01/2020 terms agreed for that policy. It does not decide generally how an opposing driver’s liability insurer must settle a claim. Different policy terms, keeping rather than selling the car, or different ownership arrangements require separate examination.
The recipient of the payment also needed particular consideration: the policyholder, the lessee and the owner were different people. Once the leasing company had been paid, the additional payment in this case belonged to the insured wife. Sections 43 and 44 of the German Insurance Contract Act and the relevant agreements therefore matter when examining the claim (paragraphs 54 to 55).
The court did not award pre-litigation legal fees. It had not been sufficiently established that the insurer was already in default before the lawyer started work (paragraph 57). The court refused permission to appeal on points of law. We do not treat that as separate confirmation that the judgment can no longer be challenged.
What should you clarify before selling and settling the claim?
Our assessment: do more than compare the two prices. Check whether both offers concern the same fully described vehicle and what costs or liability risks remain when completing the sale. Wherever possible, seek written clarification before accepting an offer, selling the car or allowing the offer to expire.
Make objections specific: which damage is missing from the description? Who pays for transport? Who is entitled to dispose of the leased car, and who should receive the insurance payment? Merely assuming that a foreign offer is too high does not replace this examination.
- Have the policy document, complete vehicle insurance terms and lease available.
- Keep the valuation report and the complete salvage offer, including the vehicle description, expiry date and collection terms.
- Gather the settlement calculation, previous payments, correspondence from the leasing company and any sale documents.
- Document payment demands and proof of receipt; have recovery of legal fees examined separately.
Sources & further information
- Munich Higher Regional Court, judgment of 19 March 2026, 14 U 2762/25 e: official full text ↗
- Section 434 German Civil Code: requirements for goods to be free of defects ↗
- Section 43 German Insurance Contract Act: insurance for the account of another ↗
- Section 44 German Insurance Contract Act: rights of the insured person ↗
- Section 286 German Civil Code: requirements for default ↗
This article provides general guidance. The options available depend on your specific situation.