Black Friday: Which price counts for the discount?
EUR 150 normally, EUR 120 in the last promotion, now EUR 90. What discount can the shop advertise? How to check the price history, percentage and presentation before Black Friday.
Why stating the right price cannot fix the wrong percentage
An Aldi Süd leaflet offered bananas for EUR 1.29 per kilo, alongside a crossed-out EUR 1.69 and a highlighted saving of 23%. Below the offer, the leaflet gave the lowest price of the previous 30 days. It too was EUR 1.29. Anyone who had bought bananas during the earlier promotion had already seen the advertised special price (CJEU, judgment of 26 September 2024, C-330/23, paragraphs 10 to 13).
The court requires the same previous low price both to be disclosed and to form the basis for the advertised saving. An announced reduction must take the price below that level. Calling an offer a “price highlight” can also fall within the rule where the claim emphasises an advantage in the context of an announced reduction (paragraphs 18 and 24 to 29).
What the shop can advertise at EUR 90
Consider a fictional online shop running a public promotion on a particular jacket. It charged EUR 150, offered the jacket for EUR 120 two weeks ago and then returned to EUR 150. On Black Friday, it plans to charge EUR 90. Against EUR 120, the customer saves EUR 30. Dividing that saving by EUR 120 gives 25%. An automatic “40% off” label would use the wrong reference price of EUR 150.
Possible wording for this specific price history is “EUR 90. Lowest total price in the 30 days before the promotion: EUR 120. Saving: 25%.” Readers must be able to associate the figures with the same item. We suggest checking the wording on the product page and wherever the discount first appears, for example on the offer tile on a phone.
Why the presentation matters under unfair competition law
The German Federal Court of Justice examined a separate coffee advertisement. A reference directed customers to a footnote listing several products and exceptions. That design failed to communicate the lowest price clearly enough. The court dismissed the discounter’s appeal on points of law. The claimant had expressly excluded the percentage calculation from its challenge (judgment of 9 October 2025, I ZR 183/24, paragraphs 1 to 5, 24 to 36 and 37 to 44).
The German court treated the unclear disclosure as withholding material information under sections 5a and 5b of the German Act Against Unfair Competition (paragraphs 45 to 52). A useful check for the shop team is whether a customer looking at the finished advert can tell which item the earlier low price belongs to and what the advertised saving is measured against.
Which promotions require a separate check
For an uninterrupted sequence of progressively larger reductions, section 11(2) of the German Price Indication Ordinance allows the retailer to keep the lowest total price from before the first stage as the reference throughout the promotion. In the jacket example, the shop went back to EUR 150 between promotions. The two promotions therefore cannot be treated as a continuous series of reductions.
Section 11(4) contains further exceptions, including individual price reductions. For perishables or goods with a short shelf life, the imminent spoilage or expiry must be the reason for the reduction, and the retailer must make this clear to consumers. The name “Black Friday” does not itself bring a public promotion on ordinary goods within either exception.
What to have ready before launch
We recommend keeping three records when checking an offer. Together, they can reveal an error where the checkout price is correct but the promotional tile calculates the discount from a different starting price.
- The price history of the specific item, including dates, total prices and previous promotions.
- The proposed saving calculated from the previous low and the new promotional price.
- A preview of the advert as it will appear on desktop and mobile.
Sources & further information
- CJEU, judgment of 26 September 2024, C-330/23: Aldi Süd, official full text ↗
- German Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 9 October 2025, I ZR 183/24: Jacobs Krönung, official full text ↗
- Section 11 German Price Indication Ordinance: price reductions on goods ↗
- Section 1 German Price Indication Ordinance: scope and clear pricing ↗
- Section 5a UWG: misleading omissions ↗
- Section 5b German Act Against Unfair Competition: material information ↗
This article provides general guidance. The options available depend on your specific situation.